In his inaugural party conference speech as prime minister, Andy Burnham declared that the Labour Party will campaign on a commitment to overhaul the UK’s electoral system at the next general election. The announcement includes the establishment of a national commission tasked with examining various options for reforming how representatives are chosen.
Burnham called on rival political parties to collaborate with the proposed body, emphasizing the need to ensure “everyone’s vote counts, and everyone’s voice is heard.” The prime minister has previously voiced support for proportional representation (PR), stating at last year’s conference that “PR’s time has come.”
The current first-past-the-post system, where candidates with the highest number of votes in each constituency win seats, has faced increasing scrutiny as Britain’s political landscape has become more fragmented. Discussion around the mechanism intensified following Labour’s decisive victory in 2024, where the party secured a substantial parliamentary majority despite receiving only 34% of the total vote share.
Recently, approximately 100 Labour MPs backed a parliamentary amendment to create a commission investigating alternative electoral methods, a position Burnham supported during his tenure as mayor of Greater Manchester. Addressing the conference, he warned against maintaining the status quo, stating, “We will all have failed in our public duties if we carry on as we are and open the door of No 10 to a divisive government on less than 30% of the vote or less.”
While the Liberal Democrats have long advocated for PR, with leaders urging Burnham to introduce it before the next election—required by 2029—the Conservatives are expected to oppose significant changes to the current system. Reform UK previously supported PR but has shown signs of cooling enthusiasm. Leader Nigel Farage told broadcasters he was willing to discuss potential changes “at some point” but argued that other issues were far more pressing.
“Is this an absolute priority for the general election after the next one? I don’t believe that it is,” Farage added. Within Labour, support is not unanimous. Deputy leader Lucy Powell acknowledged resistance in parts of the party, though she personally supports reform and noted there are “lots of models” available, declining to specify a preferred system.
Potential alternatives under review include the single transferable vote, utilized in Scottish council elections and favored by the Liberal Democrats, as well as the additional member system used for the Scottish Parliament. Earlier this year, the Welsh Senedd adopted a closed-list proportional representation system for the first time. However, Burnham did not provide specific details regarding the commission’s leadership or its timeline for commencing work.
It is quite surprising to see this much momentum for electoral reform within Labour after their massive win. Let us see if they keep their promise.
Farage saying it is not an absolute priority makes me wonder if proportional representation will even make it onto the ballot in 2029.
How will the commission decide between STV, AMS, and closed-list PR? The devil is really in the details here.
I am skeptical about any real change happening soon. Will the government actually push for this, or will it just gather dust?
About time we fixed this broken system. 34 percent for a majority is simply undemocratic and needs urgent attention.