It is a scenario familiar to many professionals: a coworker arrives at a meeting with visible symptoms of illness, such as a fever, and seems determined to push through despite the risk to others. The dilemma is compounded when a friend shows up at a social event feeling unwell, creating an awkward tension between concern for health and social etiquette. While confronting the situation can feel rude, experts say it is necessary to handle with care.
Vanessa Bohns, a social psychologist at Cornell University and author of “Should I Say Something?”, notes that suggesting someone go home can feel like a rejection, particularly if they attended because they did not want to disappoint you. “If you say something to someone and you call them out, in a way you’re judging them,” Bohns explains. “It threatens their standing as a good person.” Despite this discomfort, she insists that speaking up is worth the effort, provided the request is clear and paired with reassurance of care.
When dealing with a sick colleague or manager, Jodi R.R. Smith, an etiquette expert from Marblehead, Massachusetts, advises first considering what practical support can be offered. This might include taking notes, facilitating a remote connection, or rescheduling. Providing a graceful exit strategy makes the request more palatable. For instance, telling a coworker, “I’m going to take copious notes,” and offering to send them later can alleviate fears of missing out.
The phrasing should depend on the relationship. A manager can direct an employee to leave, whereas a peer should frame it as a request. Both experts recommend addressing the issue privately rather than calling it out in front of others. Dr. Heidi Torres, an infectious-disease physician at Weill Cornell Medicine, models this approach by telling colleagues, “You stay home, you be guilt free. We are fine. We do not need you to be here.”
Claire Smith, an occupational health psychologist at the University of South Florida, highlights that remote work can sometimes increase pressure rather than relieve it. Employees may feel they have no reason to take a sick day if they can still access their work digitally. Managers must clarify expectations regarding workload coverage to prevent the message from being interpreted as a directive to work from bed.
Systemic issues, such as a lack of paid sick leave or strict attendance policies, can force employees to choose between health and income. In these cases, specific offers of assistance can help. Asking, “Would it help if I handled the client follow-up so you could head home?” addresses immediate workload concerns, even if it does not resolve the underlying financial anxiety.
If the ill person is a supervisor, Bohns suggests framing the conversation around shared professional goals. “One of us should stay healthy for this project,” she recommends, while simultaneously requesting to join remotely. This reinforces that maintaining health is part of the commitment to the work. Dr. Torres adds that leadership must model healthy behavior; when managers ignore sick leave policies, those rules lose credibility.
In social settings, the approach shifts slightly. If a friend arrives at dinner looking ill, the host should first relieve the guest’s sense of obligation. Bohns suggests saying, “I’m so sorry you’re feeling so lousy,” followed by explicit permission to leave: “I hope you didn’t feel obligated to show up. You should definitely go home and rest.” Offering a container of food or dessert can soften the departure, while affirming that the friendship remains a priority by rescheduling future plans.
If the guest insists on staying, be direct but private. Elaine Swann, another etiquette expert, advises asking them to call it an early evening and protecting their dignity by not announcing their exit to the rest of the group. For fellow guests who are uncomfortable, Jodi Smith suggests whispering to a close friend or pulling the host aside if the relationship is distant. The host can then manage the situation according to their judgment.
When someone dismisses their illness as “just a cold,” experts advise against arguing. Instead, focus on your own boundaries. Bohns recommends responding with, “I’m just being extra careful right now,” and explaining your actions, such as moving away or stating you will stay over there. Providing context, like protecting an immunocompromised family member or preparing for an important trip, helps frame the request as personal precaution rather than judgment.
Finally, if you are the one who wishes to leave, you do not need to wait for someone else to act. Bohns points out that while we cannot read others’ thoughts, multiple people may share the same discomfort. At work, privately messaging a manager to request remote participation can be an option. At a party, a simple, warm thank-you to the host and a brief departure is sufficient. As Swann concludes, “If you don’t want to be around a sick person, make the move yourself, and don’t try to get other people involved in it.”
Leave a Reply